Horror fans love to dig deep into the genre, always searching for the next great scare. But while everyone talks about The Exorcist, Halloween, and The Shining, there are countless horror stories that have slipped through the cracks. Some were overshadowed by bigger releases, some were ahead of their time, and others were just plain forgotten. If you’re looking for hidden gems in horror fiction and film, these lost and obscure stories will scratch that itch for something new and terrifying.
Obscure Horror Books That Deserve More Attention
1. The Elementals by Michael McDowell (1981)
I love this book! Michael McDowell is best known for writing Beetlejuice, but his novel The Elementals is one of the most atmospheric horror stories you’ll ever read. Set in a decaying mansion on the Alabama Gulf Coast, the book follows a family terrorized by unseen supernatural forces. With its oppressive heat, eerie isolation, and slow-building dread, The Elementals is a Southern Gothic nightmare that horror fans should not overlook.
2. Let’s Go Play at the Adams’ by Mendal W. Johnson (1974)
If you thought The Girl Next Door was disturbing, Let’s Go Play at the Adams’ is even more brutal. This novel tells the story of a teenage babysitter who is kidnapped by the children she’s supposed to watch. What follows is a relentless descent into psychological and physical horror, as the kids’ twisted games escalate. The book is infamous for its bleakness, and while it’s not for the faint of heart, it remains one of the most disturbing horror novels ever written.
3. The Cipher by Kathe Koja (1991)
This cult classic of body horror and psychological terror revolves around a mysterious hole—called "The Funhole"—that distorts reality and consumes anything thrown into it. The novel is a bizarre, unsettling journey into obsession, transformation, and existential dread. If you love books that make you feel wrong just by reading them, The Cipher is a must.
4. The House Next Door by Anne Rivers Siddons (1978)
Unlike your typical haunted house story, this novel follows a brand-new house that corrupts and destroys the lives of everyone who lives in it. With an almost literary style, Siddons crafts a psychological horror masterpiece that proves terror doesn’t always come from ghosts—it comes from the house itself.
5. The Manitou by Graham Masterton (1976)
Graham Masterton is one of the most prolific horror writers, yet The Manitou remains criminally underrated. Mixing Native American folklore with body horror and supernatural terror, this novel follows a woman who develops a mysterious tumor that turns out to be an ancient shaman reincarnating himself. The book spawned multiple sequels, but the original remains a must-read for horror lovers.
Obscure Horror Movies You Need to See
1. Messiah of Evil (1973)
This surreal, dreamlike horror film feels like a forgotten nightmare. A young woman searching for her missing father arrives in a seaside town where the residents are eerily silent—and something monstrous lurks beneath the surface. Messiah of Evil is a slow burn with moments of pure terror, including a bloodcurdling supermarket scene that you won’t forget.
2. Let’s Scare Jessica to Death (1971)
A psychological horror film drenched in paranoia, Let’s Scare Jessica to Death follows a woman recovering from a mental breakdown who begins to suspect that the small town she’s moved to is hiding something sinister. The film’s eerie atmosphere, unreliable narrator, and haunting ambiguity make it a forgotten classic that deserves more recognition.
3. Dead & Buried (1981)
With a script co-written by Alien screenwriter Dan O’Bannon, Dead & Buried is an eerie, unsettling film about a small town with a horrifying secret. Featuring eerie reanimated corpses and a truly shocking twist, this film is a must-watch for fans of creepy, atmospheric horror.
4. The Changeling (1980)
Despite being one of the best haunted house films ever made, The Changeling has been overshadowed by films like The Shining and Poltergeist. Starring George C. Scott as a grieving composer who moves into a haunted mansion, the film delivers chilling atmosphere, a terrifying séance scene, and a ghost story that will send shivers down your spine.
5. Alice, Sweet Alice (1976)
This slasher film predates Halloween but is rarely mentioned in the same breath. Alice, Sweet Alice is a twisted murder mystery set in a deeply religious community, where a young girl is suspected of a series of brutal killings. It features eerie imagery, psychological horror, and one of the creepiest masks in horror history.
Why Do These Stories Get Forgotten?
So why do these books and films remain obscure? There are a few reasons:
Overshadowed by Bigger Titles – Many of these horror stories were released around the same time as blockbuster hits that dominated the conversation.
Marketing Failures – Some films and books suffered from poor distribution or lackluster advertising, causing them to fade into obscurity.
Ahead of Their Time – Some of these stories were too strange, disturbing, or unconventional when they were first released, but now feel more relevant than ever.
Lost to Time – Some horror books and movies just never got the widespread attention they deserved and remain hidden treasures for dedicated fans to discover.
Where to Find These Forgotten Horror Gems
Luckily, many of these lost horror stories are being rediscovered. Streaming services, boutique Blu-ray labels like Arrow Video and Scream Factory, and digital book re-releases have made it easier to track down these hidden gems. Whether you’re looking for obscure horror movies or out-of-print horror novels, there are ways to dig them up and experience the fear for yourself.
Final Thoughts
The best horror isn’t always the most famous. Sometimes, the scariest, strangest, and most unforgettable horror stories are the ones that have been buried by time. If you’re a horror fan looking for something new (or rather, old and forgotten), these books and films are waiting to be rediscovered.
What’s your favorite obscure horror book or movie? Let us know in the comments!
Be sure to visit Amazon and get my new sci-fi horror novella, Obsidian!
Or visit my online bookstore for all of my works of fiction and non-fiction.
Comments