For fans of both horror fiction and true crime, it might seem like the two genres occupy different realms of storytelling. Horror fiction is often associated with the supernatural, the fantastical, or the grotesque, while true crime is rooted in the cold, hard facts of real-life events. But look a little closer, and you’ll see these genres share a deeper connection than meets the eye. Both delve into the darkest corners of the human psyche, confront our deepest fears, and grapple with humanity’s capacity for evil. Here’s why horror fiction and true crime are two sides of the same blood-stained coin.
The Obsession With Fear and the Unknown
At their core, both horror fiction and true crime tap into our fascination with fear. Why do we willingly expose ourselves to stories that make our hearts race and send chills down our spines? Because fear is a primal emotion—it keeps us alive, warns us of danger, and, paradoxically, entertains us.
Horror fiction amplifies this fear through the lens of the unknown. Whether it’s haunted houses, vengeful spirits, or unstoppable killers, the genre thrives on pushing its audience into uncharted territory. True crime, on the other hand, evokes fear through its sheer proximity to reality. The knowledge that the murderer next door or the serial killer roaming the streets actually existed makes true crime uniquely terrifying.
Both genres appeal to our need to understand and control fear. While horror fiction allows us to confront hypothetical monsters in a safe space, true crime forces us to reckon with the monsters that already walk among us.
The Dark Side of Human Nature
Another common thread between horror fiction and true crime is their exploration of humanity’s darkest impulses. True crime often zeroes in on what drives people to commit heinous acts—greed, jealousy, rage, or even an unfathomable thirst for violence. Horror fiction, while sometimes dealing with supernatural elements, frequently uses its villains to mirror real-life human depravity. Think of the deranged serial killers in slasher films like Halloween or Psycho; their terror comes not from their supernatural abilities but from their disturbingly human motivations.
Even in supernatural horror, the true monsters are often human. In Stephen King’s The Shining, Jack Torrance’s descent into madness is as much a product of his own flaws as it is the result of the haunted Overlook Hotel. Similarly, Shirley Jackson’s We Have Always Lived in the Castle delves into paranoia, family secrets, and psychological trauma—all rooted in human nature.
True crime and horror fiction hold up a mirror to our worst instincts, making us question what lies beneath the surface of civility and whether any of us could be capable of unimaginable acts under the right circumstances.
The Power of Storytelling
Both genres rely heavily on the art of storytelling to captivate their audiences. In true crime, narrative structure is key to keeping readers and viewers engaged. It’s not enough to simply lay out the facts; true crime writers must weave these facts into a compelling narrative, complete with rising tension, dramatic reveals, and a satisfying conclusion. The best true crime stories—think In Cold Blood by Truman Capote or Michelle McNamara’s I’ll Be Gone in the Dark—read like gripping novels while maintaining journalistic integrity.
Horror fiction, meanwhile, thrives on atmosphere, suspense, and the gradual escalation of dread. Authors like Edgar Allan Poe and H.P. Lovecraft were masters of using language to build a sense of creeping unease, while modern writers like Paul Tremblay and Grady Hendrix continue to push the boundaries of what horror can achieve.
What’s fascinating is how these storytelling techniques often overlap. Many true crime writers borrow the suspense-building methods of horror fiction, while horror writers frequently draw inspiration from real-life crimes to make their stories more grounded and relatable. This symbiotic relationship ensures that both genres remain fresh and compelling.
Blurring the Lines Between Fact and Fiction
One of the most intriguing ways horror fiction and true crime intersect is through the blurring of fact and fiction. True crime often feels like a horror story brought to life, while many horror stories take inspiration from true events. Take The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, for example. While the film’s events are fictional, the character of Leatherface was loosely inspired by real-life killer Ed Gein. Similarly, Thomas Harris’s The Silence of the Lambs drew from several real-life cases, including those of Ted Bundy and Gary Heidnik.
Conversely, true crime stories are often presented with the flair of fiction. The dramatizations in Netflix’s Mindhunter or The Staircase blur the line between documentary and entertainment, crafting narratives that feel as thrilling as any horror movie.
This blending of genres raises questions about the ethics of storytelling. When does true crime become exploitative? When does horror fiction cross the line into bad taste? Both genres tread a fine line between captivating audiences and sensationalizing violence, making their intersection a fertile ground for discussion and debate.
A Cathartic Experience
One reason fans are drawn to both horror fiction and true crime is the catharsis they offer. Horror allows us to confront our fears in a controlled environment, experiencing terror without real danger. True crime, on the other hand, provides a sense of justice—or at least resolution—as we learn how criminals are caught and crimes are solved.
In both cases, these stories give us a safe space to process our anxieties about the world. Horror fiction externalizes our fears, turning them into monsters we can defeat (or at least escape from). True crime internalizes them, forcing us to confront the uncomfortable reality that danger can come from anyone, anywhere, at any time. By engaging with these stories, we’re able to better understand our own fears and, perhaps, feel a little more prepared to face them.
The Appeal to Outsiders
Horror fiction and true crime both hold a special appeal for those who feel like outsiders. These genres often focus on characters who are marginalized, misunderstood, or pushed to the fringes of society. True crime enthusiasts are often drawn to stories of societal breakdowns and the misfits who reject social norms. Similarly, horror fiction frequently celebrates the outcasts who must face down the monsters—both literal and figurative—that threaten their existence.
By diving into these worlds, fans of both genres find solidarity and understanding. Horror and true crime remind us that we’re not alone in our fears, our fascination with the macabre, or our curiosity about the darker side of life.
The Eternal Allure
Ultimately, the connection between horror fiction and true crime lies in their shared mission: to explore the limits of fear, morality, and humanity. Both genres challenge us to look beyond the surface and confront the uncomfortable truths that lurk beneath. Whether through fictional terrors or real-life horrors, these stories remind us of our vulnerability, our resilience, and our enduring fascination with the dark.
So the next time you’re bingeing a true crime documentary or curling up with a spine-chilling horror novel, take a moment to appreciate the way these two genres feed off each other. They may take different approaches, but their goal is the same: to thrill, to terrify, and to reveal the shadowy corners of the human experience.
Be sure to get my latest tale of terror - Newcomers - available at Amazon.
Or you can visit my online bookstore for all of my work in one place.
Comments